Lying About Crypto on Your Taxes Is a Huge Mistake

Jim Payne, CPA • March 4, 2025

Lying About Crypto on Your Taxes Is a Huge Mistake

Many taxpayers assume cryptocurrency is hard for the IRS to track. That assumption is flat-out wrong. The IRS has been aggressively gathering information on crypto users for years. If you lie about your holdings on Form 1040 (your tax return) or Form 433 (used when negotiating tax debts), you’re putting yourself in a very weak position when dealing with the IRS.

The IRS Likely Already Knows About Your Crypto

Since 2016, the IRS has tracked crypto transactions using blockchain analytics firms. It has also issued John Doe summonses to major exchanges like Coinbase, Kraken, and Binance, forcing them to turn over user data. If you’ve ever bought, sold, or traded crypto on a major platform, there's a good chance the IRS already has records of your activity.


That means the IRS can easily cross-check its database and uncover the truth if you check "No" on the crypto question on Form 1040 or leave out crypto assets on Form 433. Once they catch you in a lie, your credibility is gone.

The Consequences: Civil and Criminal Penalties

Lying on a tax return is a federal offense. If the IRS determines you willfully misrepresented your crypto activity, you could face:

  • Civil penalties – Up to 75% of unpaid tax for fraud.
  • Accuracy-related penalties 20% penalty for underreporting taxable income.
  • Criminal prosecution – Filing a false tax return (26 U.S. Code § 7206) can result in three years in prison and fines up to $250,000.

Lying on Form 433 Can Destroy Your Negotiating Power

If you owe back taxes and are applying for an Installment Agreement (IA), Offer in Compromise (OIC), or Currently Not Collectible (CNC) status, you must disclose your financial situation on Form 433 (A, B, or F).

Leaving out crypto holdings may seem like a way to look less able to pay, but if the IRS finds out you hid assets, they can:

  • Reject your payment plan or settlement offer.
  • Demand immediate full payment of your tax debt.
  • Refer your case for criminal investigation.

Once the IRS knows you lied, your leverage is gone. Instead of negotiating in good faith, you’ll be threatened by fraud charges. At that point, the IRS isn’t just looking to settle—they may be looking to punish.

"My Preparer Didn’t Ask" Is a Weak Excuse

Some taxpayers think they can blame their tax preparer if they get caught hiding crypto. Wrong. The IRS holds you responsible for what’s on your return—not your preparer.

Since the crypto question is front and center on Form 1040, the IRS won’t accept "I didn’t realize I had to report it" as an excuse. The same goes for Form 433—if you leave out crypto, the IRS will assume it was intentional, and that’s when things get serious.

The Smart Move: Full Disclosure

If you have crypto holdings:

  1. Report them accurately on 1040 and Form 433. The IRS likely already has your data.
  2. Keep detailed records of all transactions—buys, sells, transfers, and staking rewards.
  3. If you failed to report crypto in past years, consider amending your returns before the IRS contacts you.

Final Thoughts: Don’t Gamble With the IRS

Lying about crypto isn’t just a bad idea—it’s a disaster waiting to happen. The IRS is more sophisticated than ever and likely already knows about your holdings. If you lie, you risk massive penalties, criminal charges, and losing all credibility when negotiating tax relief.

And if you think blaming your tax preparer will save you, think again. You are responsible for your tax return.

When it comes to cryptocurrency, lying to the IRS isn’t just risky—it’s a losing game. Once they catch you, penalties, criminal charges, and lost negotiating power could be just the beginning.

A piece of paper that says irs audit on it
By Jim Payne, CPA July 22, 2025
Services for Real Estate Pros with Backoffice Squared March 11, 2025 07:30 AM No one wants to deal with an IRS audit, but here’s the good news: the chances of facing one are shrinking. Traditional IRS audits will become rarer due to recent layoffs and a shift toward automation. And with the right strategy, you can make tax season even easier for yourself. Why Field and Office Audits Are Disappearing In February 2025, the IRS laid off about 6,700 employees , including many revenue agents responsible for auditing high-income taxpayers and businesses. With fewer auditors, the IRS doesn’t have the resources to conduct as many in-person audits. Field audits (where an IRS agent visits your home or business) will happen far less often. Office audits (where you go to an IRS office to clear up tax issues) will also decline. So, unless you have a seriously complicated tax situation, the odds of sitting across from an IRS agent are lower than they’ve been in years. The Shift to Mail Audits & Automated Enforcement Instead of in-person audits, the IRS will focus on correspondence audits —tax checks done through mail or electronic communication. These usually target: Mismatched income reports (W-2s or 1099s that don’t match your return). Missing tax forms. Unusual deductions or credits. While these audits are less stressful, they can still be a hassle if you don’t respond quickly. With fewer audit people available, resolving issues could take longer. A Smart Strategy: Filing an Extension & Checking Transcripts One of the main reasons taxpayers get audited is mismatched income reporting —when what you report doesn’t match what the IRS has on file. The best way to avoid this? Wait until your IRS Wage and Income Transcript is available before filing. Here’s why it works: The IRS releases these transcripts in May or June , showing all W-2s, 1099s, and other reported income. By filing an extension until October , you can check your transcript before submitting your return. This ensures everything matches, reducing the risk of an audit or correction notice. Filing an extension doesn’t increase your audit risk, giving you extra time to ensure accuracy. Remember: if you owe taxes, you must pay by the April deadline to avoid penalties. What This Means for You With fewer IRS agents, in-person audits are less likely, but automated enforcement is still in play. To stay out of trouble: File an extension and check your Wage and Income Transcript before submitting. Keep records of deductions and credits in case of a mail audit. Respond to IRS letters quickly if you get one—ignoring them won’t make them go away.  Final Thoughts The IRS will be changing its audit strategies. By filing smart —waiting for your income transcripts and ensuring everything matches—you can reduce your audit risk and avoid unnecessary headaches. A little patience and accuracy can save you big down the road.
By Jim Payne July 19, 2025
Tax season can be stressful, and nothing makes it worse than getting a Form 1099-K that’s incorrect. Whether the amount reported is too high, too low, or just completely wrong, it’s important to address the issue quickly to avoid headaches with the IRS. Here’s what you need to know if you receive a bad 1099-K.
July 17, 2025
Here’s one of my predictions for the next few years—thanks to recent IRS layoffs and ongoing staffing shortages, more Offers in Compromise (OICs) are going to slip through the cracks. And when that happens, some taxpayers might see their tax debt automatically settled without the IRS ever reviewing their case. Sound too good to be true? It’s not. There’s a little-known rule that works in your favor:
July 17, 2025
Owe the IRS more than you can afford? An Offer in Compromise (OIC) might let you settle for less than the full amount . Sounds great, right? Well, the IRS doesn’t make it easy. Most OICs get rejected because people don’t understand the process or submit unrealistic offers. Here’s how to do it right and boost your approval chances.
A person is filling out a tax form with a pen
By Jim Payne, CPA March 6, 2025
How Final is the IRS Final Notice of Intent to Levy?
A person is writing on a piece of paper next to a calculator.
By Jim Payne, CPA February 11, 2025
Understanding the Three Types of Innocent Spouse Relief